Looking at modern home automation communication technologies (like Z-Wave or Zigbee), it seems that most of them have some security issues. These may or may not been fixed in the future. If these modern architectures already show a lot of problems, what about KNX? Let’s make it quick: from an computer security point of view, KNX is not just insecure, but the worst kind of protocol. All devices communicate on a shared medium, there is no encryption, no authentication, no authorisation. If you have access to the KNX bus, you can do everything.
Luckily, there is one good thing about KNX: You need access to the bus. If somebody has physical access to your bus, he can do crazy things. But this means, this person is already in your flat. Even without home automation, a person that has physical access to a light switch can turn it on and off. This means that for a residential installation, cabled KNX installations are perfectly fine, if they are running standalone. However, modern installations aren’t standalone. Nobody wants to install an home automation system anymore that is not somehow connected to a network.
Here are some tips how to make sure this system is still secure.
- Don’t simply connect your KNX network to your home LAN (that might be even allow guest WLAN access).
KNX/IP interfaces are cool products and you will need one. However, be clear that these do not have any security built in. That means everybody that has access to your network can do everything on your home automation installation. This might not be the best idea. I would recommend some gateway that makes sure only authorised system can access your KNX bus.
- If you use any commercial product to connect your KNX bus to your LAN, (there are a lot of products available) make sure, the supplier provides regular updates and reacts on security incidents. If the last firmware you can find is 17 months old, the supplier most likely doesn’t do a good job. Most of these gateways are Linux based and you will need regular updates for it.
- If you implement some kind of gateway/firewall by yourself, make sure it is designed with security in mind and you also update it regularly.
Remark 1: The concept of physical security can be very critical in environments where multiple parties share a KNX installation. This can be a problem not only in office buildings, but also apartment complexes. If you live in an apartment with some kind of “smart” technology, have a look how it is implemented and who might be able to access it.
Remark 2: With ETS 5.5 the KNX association now supports some kind of encryption. I haven’t looked into it. Why? Because all old devices do not have any idea about it. It might become more popular in the future, but in today’s practical KNX installations, it is usually not supported by the devices that are already in place.